Monday, 10 November 2008

SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE commands Top Spot




















































































































































































































































































































TODAY'S IMAGES
Plate 1: Map, courtesy of Ordnance Survey, revealing the location of Horse Shoe Point Car Park
Plates 2-4: first-winter SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE, Grainthorpe Haven, North Lincolnshire, November 2008 (Peter Beesley); plates 5-6 (Simon Knight)
Plate 7: first-winter female DESERT WHEATEAR, Saltfleet Haven, North Lincolnshire, November 2008 (Simon Knight)
Plates 8-11: male TWO-BARRED CROSSBILL, Garfit Farm Feeders, North Yorkshire Moors, November 2008 (Tony Dixon)
Plates 12-14: adult female HOODED MERGANSER, Tayport Pond, Fife, November 2008
Plate 15: AMERICAN GREEN-BACKED HERON, West Hythe, Kent, November 2008 (Gary Thoburn)
Plates 18-20: first-winter female DESERT WHEATEAR, Saltfleet, North Lincolnshire, November 2008
Plates 16-17: male DESERT WHEATEAR, Southwold, Suffolk, November 2008 (Stuart Read)
Plates 21-23: adult COMMON CRANE, Modbury, South Devon, November 2008 (Dave Stone)
Plates 24-25: OSPREY, Stoke-by-Nayland, Suffolk, November 2008 (Sean Nixon)
Plates 26-27: drake Aythya duck closely resembling drake Canvasback, Nosterfield GP, North Yorkshire, 8 November 2008 (Richard Bayldon)


The first-winter SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE remains at Grainthorpe Haven (North Lincolnshire), showing down to just a few feet at times. It is frequenting a line of isolated Hawthorn bushes adjacent to the coastal footpath and more often the ploughed field adjacent to the ditch.

DETAILED DIRECTIONS: The area is best approached from the A18, from where a minor road runs due east to North Thoresby. Continue east through the village on the B1201 and continue until where it joins the coastal A1301. Turn right here and continue towards Mablethorpe. After just under two miles and just beyond the first sharp right hand bend in Marshchapel, turn left towards the coast and continue for two miles to Horse Shoe Point Beach Car Park. This is a very narrow lane with a deep dyke to its north so please take extra care.

Once in the car park, please note that this is a very long, very muddy and arduous walk to the shrike site, which will take at least 20 minutes to walk. Follow the sea wall south, crossing the stile, for 0.8 miles to the Pumping Station. Turn right here, walk through the gate (making sure to close it afterwards) and follow the road for 700 yards to the first concrete bridge. The shrike often favours this spot, perching on the concrete bridge or feeding in the ploughed field alongside. It also shelters out of the wind in the short reeds at the top of the ditch. If unlucky, and the bird has been pushed further south, it will be in the hedgerow bordering the public footpath, accessed by crossing the bridge, walking back towards the sea and then turning right after 100 yards. The bird can then be 2-300 yards down this footpath, depending on tolerability.

Unfortunately, because the bird is so confiding and approachable, it has been extremely popular with photographers of all levels of competence, and has been repeatedly disturbed at times. This is totally unnecessary as with a little patience, it will approach observers and afford visitors with views down to a few feet. It has no fear or real perception of man. DO NOT, UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES, REPEATEDLY HARASS THE BIRD AND ALLOW IT TO FEED. There are more than enough images available of exceptional quality.

THERE IS NO OFFICIAL ACCESS DOWN KEYHOLME LANE AND THOSE WITHOUT PERMITS WILL BE REMOVED. THIS TRACK IS PRIVATELY OWNED.

Less than six miles away to the south, a first-winter female DESERT WHEATEAR is equally confiding and present for its third day at Saltfleet Haven (North Lincs). Although the A1301 is currently closed at Saltfleet Bridge, one can drive just north of the wheatear site. Turn left along the north side of the river on a very rough track towards the haven and after 400 yards park. Continue through the gap in the dunes and walk east for 100 yards to view the bird feeding on the edge of the dunes.

A TUNDRA BEAN GOOSE is also at Saltfleet, favouring the flooded field just inland from the sea wall just south of the caravan park

In North Yorkshire, another 'showstopper' is a fabulous male TWO-BARRED CROSSBILL favouring peanut feeders in an isolated North Yorkshire Moor garden. The bird has been visiting the garden since 24 October 2008 and is most reliable between 0900 and 1100 hours. It generally favours the nut feeder in the front garden of Garfit Farm (NZ 563 030) but this weekend, due to the amount of disturbance from visiting birders, it chose to visit the feeder in the back garden. The owners of the farm have been most hospitable in their choice to release news of this beautiful bird so please respect their privacy and do not trample the garden or damage the eloquent stone walls by the pond. The bird regularly perched in the tall Larches adjacent to the Farm Pond. Six Common Crossbills are also in the area.

DETAILED DIRECTIONS: Garfit Farm lies to the west of the B1257, 4 miles SE of Stokesley. Park carefully on the verge about half a mile south of the Clay Bank Car Park and follow the steep uphill entrance to the farm for just over half a mile. The farmer has kindly agreed to allow the infirm and disabled to drive to the farm but please park sensibly and carefully on the grass just before the farm gate - there is room for just four vehicles.

Also in North Yorkshire, a first-winter female PIED WHEATEAR remains for a third day at Reighton Sands Holiday Park, 4 miles south of Filey, favouring the grass situated by the southeasternmost caravans and the deep ravine dropping down to the beach.

Three further DESERT WHEATEARS are present on the East Coast of Britain, with first-winter males just SE of Lynemouth (Northumberland) (on the flat, gravelly area south of the lagoon on the east side of the dunes, 1,000 yards south of the Power Station) and just north of Southwold (Suffolk) at Easton Bavents Cliffs and a first-winter female on the Royal Cinques Golf Course at Sandwich Bay (East Kent).

An elusive first-winter RED-FLANKED BLUETAIL remains for its 4th day on Holy Island (Northumberland), favouring Sycamores opposite the Lindisfarne Hotel, whilst yet another one - the 14th this autumn - was trapped and ringed at Hollesley (Suffolk) on 8th.

The first twitchable CATTLE EGRET for Oxfordshire was this morning with cattle in the large grass field adjacent to the Day's Lock NR scrape, between Dorchester-on-Thames and Little Whittenham (Tony Williams, Nic Hallam et al), whilst in London, a SQUACCO HERON (the first of the year) flew past Rainham Marsh RSPB Visitor Centre at 1430 hours (Howard Vaughan) (at least 1 EUROPEAN SERIN and the long-staying Dartford Warbler also remain here, just inland of the sea wall).

A few PALLAS'S LEAF WARBLERS linger from the weekend, with singles at Kingsgate, Stonehaven (Aberdeenshire) and at Newbiggin Mound (Northumberland), whilst a Siberian Lesser Whitethroat is present for its third day at garden feeders at Halistra, Waternish Point, Isle of Skye (Highland).

The adult female HOODED MERGANSER of perhaps suspect origin remains on Tayport Pond (Fife), often allowing approach to within 40 yards, with the 2nd-winter drake also still present at Radipole Lake RSPB (Dorset), after completing a summer residency at the site.

The female RING-NECKED DUCK has reappeared on Bassenthwaite Lake (Cumbria) (view from the hide), with a flock of 8 at Chew Valley Lake (Avon) on 9th (with 5 remaining today), whilst a flurry of LESSER SCAUPS include a female on Helston Boating Lake (Cornwall) and a first-winter drake on Lydney Lakes (Gloucs), a mile south of Lydney NE of Harbour Road and south of the railway. The drake KING EIDER remains off Appledore (North Devon) with a SURF SCOTER off Seaton Hole (South Devon).

In Norfolk, a DOTTEREL is still consorting with 900 European Golden Plovers near Hill Harling Farm at TM 005 853, near East Harling (Norfolk) In Suffolk, the long-staying juvenile OSPREY remains at Stoke-by-Nayland Golf Course pond

The long-staying GREAT WHITE EGRET remains just south of Astley Green (Gtr Manchester) by Rindle Road (SJ 705 975) with another on Ivy Lake, Blashford Lakes HWT (Hants)

GREAT NORTHERN DIVERS remain inland at Carsington Water (Derbyshire), Girton Sailing Pit (Notts), Chasewater (Staffs), Rutland Water (Leics), Farmoor Reservoir (Oxon) (2 birds) and Staines Reservoirs (Surrey), with a Long-tailed Duck still at Blithfield Reservoir (Staffs)

In IRELAND, a LESSER SCAUP is at Laddenwell, Lough Ennell (Co. Westmeath) whilst the regular white morph SNOW GOOSE is with Greenland White-fronted Geese at North Slob WWR (Co. Wexford).

Friday, 7 November 2008

New Record Well and Truly Set

With today's SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE in North Lincolnshire, the total number of species now recorded in Britain and Ireland in 2008 increases to an absolutely staggering 441 species - 7 clear of last year's record.

Since my last update, the following species have been added -:

BLACK-THROATED THRUSH - first-winter at Holme, Norfolk
PINE BUNTING - St Osyth, Essex, late October
ROSE-BREASTED GROSBEAK - first-winter at Kilbaha in County Clare IRELAND

Two further species are still under review - a drake CANVASBACK in North Yorkshire (identification) and two HOODED MERGANSERS of unknown origin (in Dorset and in Fife - category status to be decided)

SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE IN NORTH LINCOLNSHIRE AND ITS STATUS IN BRITAIN





This first-winter SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE was located just inland of Grainthorpe Haven, North Lincolnshire, this afternoon, and was video-filmed by local birder Roy Harvey (see video-grabs above)
It represents only the 19th record for Britain, is the first for Lincolnshire and the first 'widely twitchable' bird in Britain since that in Essex in 1996

The previous records are as follows
1956 Shetland Fair Isle, first-winter, trapped, 21st September (FIBOR 1955/56: 25; FIBOB (Vol. 3, No. 3) 1957: 111; British Birds 50: 246-249; Thom, 1986).
1964 Shetland Fair Isle, first-winter, trapped, 18th October (British Birds 58: 368; 66: 401-402).
1986 Suffolk Landguard NR, trapped, 6th December (British Birds 81: 587; Twitching 1: 50).
1989 North Yorkshire Bishop Monkton, probably first-winter, 31st October to 1st November (British Birds 91: 511).
1989 Dorset Portland, first-winter, 1st November (British Birds 86: 524).
1992 Cornwall Cape Cornwall and Kenidjack Carn, 21st to 23rd April (British Birds 86: 524, 527, plates 196-197; 88: 288-290).
1992 Suffolk Easton Bavents and Southwold, 4th to 7th October (British Birds 86: 524).
1993 Wiltshire Swindon, first-winter, taken into care injured, 23rd September. released 24th, present to 28th (British Birds 87: 560, 562, plate 167).
1994 Orkney North Ronaldsay, first-winter male, 14th September to 16th October, trapped 5th. Papa Westray, 11th to 26th November (British Birds 88: 543, 552, plates 187-189; Scottish Bird Report 1994: 58).
1994 Essex Great Wakering, first-winter, 26th to 30th October (British Birds 90: 504).
1994 Cumbria South Walney, first-winter, 2nd November (British Birds 88: 543).
1994 Shetland Boddam, probably first-winter, 7th to 10th November (British Birds 88: 543, 545; Scottish Bird Report 1994: 58).
1996 Essex Holland-on-Sea, first-winter, 18th November to at least 4th December (British Birds 90: 504, plate 183).
1997 Northamptonshire Long Buckby, first-winter, 3rd to 4th November (British Birds 91: 511).
2000 Orkney Windwick, South Ronaldsay, first-winter, 22nd September (British Birds 94: 496)
2003 Isle of Man Ballaghennie Ayres, first-summer male, in song, 17th June to 12th July (Birding World 16: 248-251, plates 1-5; British Birds 96: plate 278: 97: plate 364 – 97: 616)
2004 Kent Ash, first-winter, 6th-7th November (Brtish Birds 98: 684).

RED-BREASTED GOOSE in HAMPSHIRE






Adult Red-breasted Goose, Pennington Marshes, Hampshire, 6-7 November 2008 (Richard Coomber)
Presumably last year's wintering bird

Hi Lee,
I had a call from the finder, who said he had picked it up arriving with Dark-bellied Brent Geese. It joined the Canada Goose flock at Lower Pennington for a while. This morning, it was back with the Brents, roosting off the Butts Lagoon. After a while it got flighty and moved to Fishtail Lagoon and then back out on to the saltgrass nr Hurst Castle. We could see no rings, and given the way it was behaving this morning, we saw no reason why it wasn't a wild bird.
Steve P.

EASTERN SHRIKE CONSTITUTES LATEST MEGA TO GRACE BRITAIN'S SHORES
















RED-FLANKED BLUETAIL, Blakeney Point, Norfolk, 6 November 2008 (James Gilroy) - a particularly good find and well deserved for this excellent pioneering birder
RED-FLANKED BLUETAIL, Muckleburgh Hill, Norfolk, 1-5 November 2008 (Nick Green) - a superb image and a fabulous bird and well received by the 450+ observers that twitched it
First-winter male DESERT WHEATEAR, Easton Bavents Cliff, Southwold, Suffolk, 4-7 November 2008 (Matthew Deans)
HUME'S LEAF WARBLER, Unst, Shetland, 4-7 November 2008 (George Petrie) - one of three identified thi spast week
FRIDAY 7 NOVEMBER 2008

This autumn just keeps on running - breaking all previous records in terms of number of species recorded.

Today saw yet another haul of 'Eastern Surprises' - with RED-FLANKED BLUETAILS now almost as common as European Robins !

Today's RED-FLANKED BLUETAIL was on Holy Island (Northumberland), where it favoured the Vicar's Garden throughout the day, often showing well. Although there was no sign of yesterday's Bluetail on Blakeney Point (Norfolk), that location today yielded a RADDE'S WARBLER at Halfway House. A further RADDE'S WARBLER was in short grass between the clifftop path and Plantation at the north end of Easington Gas Terminal (East Yorks), with yet another in scrub on the north side of Castle Hill, Scarborough (North Yorks) - all very late dates for this Siberian species.

Pride of place however was taken by a first-winter SAXAUL GREY SHRIKE (only the 19th British record and the first since a first-summer male on the Isle of Man in June-July 2003) showing well until dusk on hedgerows just west of Grainthorpe Haven (North Lincs). Grainthorpe Haven is situated 10 miles NE of Louth and 2 miles NNE of Grainthorpe. The bird is in the hedge just west of the Haven accessed by walking SE from Horse Shoe Point for 0.8 miles, The last twitchable bird in Britain, discounting the Isle of Man bird, was in Essex in November 1996.

The first-winter male DESERT WHEATEAR remains at the south end of Easton Bavents Cliffs, just north of Southwold (Suffolk), whilst a second bird, a first-winter female, was discovered south of Sandwich Bay Estate (East Kent) at the Royal Cinque Ports Golf Course this afternoon (park by the Chequers Public House north of Deal then take the footpath east to the beach, where the bird is favouring the beach by the 6th tee).

PALLAS'S LEAF WARBLERS remained at Sands of Forvie NNR (Aberdeenshire), East Links Road, Dunbar (Lothian), Hartlepool Headland (Cleveland)(2 birds), Filey Arndale Ravine (North Yorks), Kilnsea (East Yorks) and at Donna Nook (North Lincs) with 'new arrivals' at Kergord (Shetland), Donmouth (Aberdeenshire) (in King's Links), Castle Hill, Scarborough (North Yorks), on Holy Island (Northumberland), Aldbrough Fish Ponds (East Yorks) and at Westgate (Kent).

An adult male TWO-BARRED CROSSBILL, present for two weeks, visited the garden peanut feeders again today, 4 miles SE of Stokesley and just west of Urra (Cleveland). Garfitts Farm is situated west of the B1257 and after 0800 hours tomorrow, special permission has been granted for birders to visit the site (NZ 563 030). PLEASE FOLLOW ANY ON-SITE INSTRUCTIONS.

Along with a BLUETHROAT on the Farne Islands (Northumberland), at least 6 NORTHERN GREY SHRIKES appeared on the East Coast, with a HUME'S LEAF WARBLER in Sallows near the toilet block on St Mary's Island (Northumberland) and another on North Ronaldsay (Orkney).. An OLIVE-BACKED PIPIT was at Beosetter on Bressay (Shetland).

An adult RED-BREASTED GOOSE remains with Dark-bellied Brent Geese for a second day at Pennington Marshes (Hants), whilst two TUNDRA BEAN GEESE were again at Belvide Reservoir (Staffs).

The juvenile ROUGH-LEGGED BUZZARD at the Royal Liverpool Golf Course adjacent to Red Rocks Marsh NR, Hoylake (Wirral), remained in its tree overnight but then flew off at 0845, with another east over Scamblesby (Lincs) this afternoon. A Dark-breasted Barn Owl was seen just south of Embleton (Northumberland) this evening.

In East Kent, the first-winter AMERICAN GREEN-BACKED HERON remains on the Royal Military Canal at West Hythe, whilst a CATTLE EGRET was an excellent Shropshire find feeding in sheepfields just south of Ellesmere, 200 yards from Blackwater Meadow Marina between the plantation and the canal. In Hampshire, a CATTLE EGRET was also present near Bransbury Common before flying east, with another on Rimmer's Marsh, Marshside RSPB (Lancs). Meanwhile, this week's Home Counties GREAT WHITE EGRET flew SW over Spellbrook (Herts) at 1605 (Stephen Patmore).

A single first-winter EUROPEAN SERIN remains in weeds at Rainham Marsh RSPB (London).
The HOODED MERGANSER remains on Tayport Pond (Fife) with this summer's drake still present at Radipole Lake RSPB (Dorset).

The adult COMMON CRANE was again in the stubble field south of the A379 (SX 638 516) west of Modbury (South Devon) this afternoon (view from the first gate beyond Goutsford Bridge on the Orcheton road).

Thursday, 6 November 2008

YET MORE RED-FLANKED BLUETAILS APPEAR - 6 NOVEMBER 2008 SIGHTINGS




















































































































































TODAY'S IMAGES
PALLAS'S LEAF WARBLERS photographed in North Lincolnshire this week (Graham Catley) - at least 7 different birds being recorded in the county.
GREY PHALAROPE, Farmoor Reservoirs, Oxfordshire, 3-5 November (Stephen Burch)
BOHEMIAN WAXWINGS in Norfolk (Simon Chidwick) - a huge immigration is taking place
AMERICAN GREEN-BACKED HERON at West Hythe (Kent) (Simon Knight) - one of the most confiding birds of the year.
RED-FLANKED BLUETAIL, Ramsgate Cemetery, Kent, 1-2 November (Michael Southcott)
Adult female HOODED MERGANSER, Tayport Pond, Lothian, November - one of two birds currently present in the country
Drake LESSER SCAUP, Hogganfield Loch, Clyde, November (Ian Fulton)
2nd-winter drake KING EIDER off Appledore, North Devon (Gary Thoburn)


This is the UK400 Club Rare Bird Alert for Thursday 6 November 2008, issued at 1900 hours and published in association with Rare Bird Alert Pagers (http://www.rarebirdalert.co.uk/) whilst utilising additional information gleaned from BirdGuides (http://www.birdguides.com/), the regional Birdlines, local email groups and websites and individual observers.

The Siberian theme of recent weeks continues: two more RED-FLANKED BLUETAILS were discovered today with first-winters at Chapel Six Marshes, Chapel St Leonards (Lincs) and in Marrams at The Hood on Blakeney Point (Norfolk) this afternoon. Meanwhile, a superb first-winter male DESERT WHEATEAR remains for a third day at Easton Bavents, Southwold (Suffolk), along the sea wall just north of Southwold Boating Lake (John Geeson, et al). It is frequenting groynes at the south end of Easton Bavents Cliffs, as well as the sheep paddocks just south of the first houses on the foreshore.

PALLAS'S LEAF WARBLERS today include singles on North Ronaldsay (Orkney) and at Sands of Forvie NNR (Aberdeenshire), Roxburgh Terrace, Dunbar (Lothian), Filey Arndale Ravine (North Yorks), Grimston (East Yorks), Kilnsea (East Yorks) (in Sallows in the Crown & Anchor car park), Holme NOA (Norfolk) and on Blakeney Point (Norfolk), whilst YELLOW-BROWED WARBLERS include 2 at Holme NOA (Norfolk) and further singles at Hartlepool Headland (Cleveland), South Gare (Cleveland), on Bardsey Island (Gwynedd), Cley village (Norfolk), Porthcurno (Cornwall), Carmarthen National Wetlands Centre, in Maples near Nantyfflon surgery (SS 852 924) (Glamorgan), in Foundry Close, Easton (Portland, Dorset) and at Newford Duckpond, St Mary's (Scilly). A very elusive DUSKY WARBLER remains on Mucklenurgh Hill, Weybourne (Norfolk) with another in Buckthorn near Post 61 at Spurn Point (East Yorks).

Large numbers of BOHEMIAN WAXWINGS continue to arrive, with 23 on North Ronaldsay (Orkney), 45 in Kirkwall (Orkney), 9 on Shapinsay (Orkney), 6 in Deerness (Orkney), 98 in Cromarty (Highland), 50 in Sanquhar Road, Forres (Moray), 70 in Allenvale Cemetery, Aberdeen, 18 in Seafield Road, Aberdeen, 100 in Dyce (Aberdeenshire), 100 in Westhill (Aberdeenshire), 8 at Balcomie (Fife), 27 in Longniddry (Lothian), 21 on Whelton Road, Morpeth (Northumberland), 3 on Hartlepool Headland (Cleveland), 55 inland over South Gare (Cleveland), 5 at Saltwick Nab (North Yorks), 5 at Filey NCCP (North Yorks), 24 in Weybourne (Norfolk), 39 in Overstrand (Norfolk), 4 in Silvergate, Blickling (Norfolk), 4 at Norwich UEA (Norfolk), 5 in Haddiscoe (Norfolk), 3 in St Edmund's Churchyard, Southwold (Suffolk), 10 over Church Road, Stansted Mountfichet (Essex), 3 in Shepreth (Cambs) and 2 over Otmoor RSPB (Oxon).

In East Kent, the first-winter AMERICAN GREEN-BACKED HERON continues to show very well at the dammed section of the Royal Military Canal at West Hythe, whilst in West Cornwall, the 2nd-winter AZOREAN YELLOW-LEGGED GULL remains in fields by Skewjack Farm.

In Cheshire, a juvenile ROUGH-LEGGED BUZZARD was seen for a second day on Hilbre Island this morning, being later flushed from Cubbin's Green, West Kirby, where it flew SW across the Dee Estuary. It then reappeared over Hoylake Golf Course mid-afternoon, where it roosted in a tree until dusk. Another good local bird, a NORTHERN GREY SHRIKE, reappeared for a second day in trees along the service road behind the sludge pits at Farmoor Reservoirs (Oxon) this afternoon.

In Essex, a first-winter GREY PHALAROPE remains for its 4th day at Howlands Marsh NR (Essex) (from Wigeon Hide) whilst in Gwent, a late PECTORAL SANDPIPER was again on Goldcliff Lagoons.

On Fair Isle, 2 Siberian Chiffchaffs remain, as well as a Shore Lark (5th) and a light Bohemian Waxwing passage, with a female BLUETHROAT a late migrant at Girdle Ness (Aberdeenshire).

The long-staying GREAT WHITE EGRET remains by Rindle Road, Astley Green (Gtr Manchester), best viewed from a vehicle at SJ 705 975 to avoid disturbance, whilst in Cambridgeshire, 2 CATTLE EGRETS remained with cattle in fields north of Buckden Marina until 2nd. A further CATTLE EGRET remains in the cattle field above the chapel in Sandy Haven (Pembs). An adult COMMON CRANE remains for its 5th day 2 miles west of Modbury (South Devon) in the stubble field south of the A379 (view from the gate at SX 638 516).

An adult Red-breasted Goose (of unknown origin) was with Canada Geese at Pennington Marshes (Hants) today, whilst 2 TUNDRA BEAN GEESE were an excellent record for Belvide Reservoir (Staffs) mid-afternoon (on the North Shore viewed from West Hide but flew off west at 1512). Two more were with Greylag Geese at Humberstone Fitties (North Lincs).

Adult drake LESSER SCAUPS remain on Hogganfield Loch (Clyde) and the A52 Pit at Holme Pierrpont (Notts), whilst the juvenile SURF SCOTER remains with Common Scoters off Pendower Beach (SW 905 380) (Cornwall). The female SURF SCOTER remains in Tor Bay, Preston (Torquay, South Devon) (view from Marine Drive), the same bay holding 3 Black-necked Grebes, whilst in North Devon, the 2nd-winter KING EIDER can still be easily located in Appledore between the Lifeboat Station and the Church Fields Car Park. The adult female HOODED MERGANSER is again this afternoon on Tayport Pond (Fife) at NO 462 285 with a drake still showing well at Radipole Lake RSPB (Dorset).

The juvenile Great Northern Diver remains at Grafham Water (Cambs), with a Red-necked Grebe on Draycote Water (Warks), with further Great Northerns at Girton Sailing Lake (Notts) and on Staines Reservoirs South Basin (Surrey). Inland Red-breasted Mergansers displaced inland include 2 juveniles on Coate Water CP (Wilts) and another on Grovebury Sand Pit (Beds)

A late juvenile Osprey is still present in the Stoke-by-Nayland area (Suffolk), fishing for its 10th day in a row on the Golf Club lake, whilst a late Common Swift was at Hills Green Farm, Hackness (North Yorks), late morning.

A LAPLAND BUNTING is consorting with Skylarks on the Holden Tower scrape at Slimbridge WWT (Gloucs) whilst in London, a SNOW BUNTING remains for its 4th day at Rainham Marsh RSPB. A single TWITE (an excellent London tick these days) is also still with Linnets near the Landfill Site, 1.2 kms west of the Information Centre.

On the Isles of Scilly, a Eurasian Bittern was seen twice on Porthellick Pool, St Mary's (Scilly) - an excellent Scilly tick (the juvenile SNOWY OWL was last seen on St Martin's on 2nd November)

Tuesday, 4 November 2008

HOODED MERGANSER IN FIFE - A DISCUSSION OF ITS AGEING












































































Hooded Merganser, Tayport Pond, Fife, 26 October to at least 4 November 2008
All images taken by Edinburgh birder Kris Gibb











































































Captive Hooded Mergansers photographed at Slimbridge WWT (Keith Vinicombe)
Plate 1) juvenile in hand; 2) juvenile male (note pale eye colour); 3) first-winter female; 4) juvenile and 5) ADULT female
The ageing and sexing of Hooded Mergansers in autumn is notoriously difficult but summarised on this excellent website here -:
After much consultation and study, I believe the Fife bird to be an ADULT FEMALE
My decision was made after consulting North American experts, browsing a fabulous wildfowl website (which portrays upper and underwings of all Nearctic ducks), consulting the UK400 Club Identification Panel including Keith Vinicombe who stands as the Club's wildfowl consultant and after studying some excellent images sent in by Kris Gibb. I also consulted widely with those that have seen the bird (eg, Rab Shand, the Fife county recorder) and also with Birdline Scotland.

The bird in our view is an adult female, based on the brightness of the eye colour, the extent of yellow at the base of the lower mandible (which also extends on to the upper mandible) and the broadness, extent and brightness of the white greater covert bar. It also has a noticeable crest, although this feature is marginal as first-winters quickly attain a crest in their first autumn. Furthermore, the shiny black tertials have longitudinal white stripes within them, and the bird has broad and rounded tail feathers. Juvenile Hooded Mergansers invariably have just plain dark brown upperparts and flanks whereas adult females have much darker (often blackish) mantle, back and scapulars and much greyer sides (with varying amounts of grey in the face).
When roosting out of the water, the right leg appears to be slightly damaged, suggesting that it may have once bore a ring.
LEE EVANS
BRITISH BIRDING ASSOCIATION